Down the wrong Laine

There seems to be no dearth of divisive issues which the politicians can exploit to create strife and trouble in our society. The latest episode revolves around the book “Shivaji – Hindu King in Islamic India”. This book authored by American writer James Laine was first published in 2003 and promptly banned by the Maharashtra govt in 2004. There were loud and often violent protests before the ban led by various organisations like the Sambhaji Brigade. The book is again in the lime light as the Supreme court did not uphold the ban as the state govt could not submit evidence that the book was hurting religious sentiments.

This time around the scene is pretty unique with the ultra nationalistic state govt also joining in the chorus for the ban on the sale of book. There are the usual culprits like the shiv sena, MNS and Sambhaji brigade and they have threatened to resort to violent protests to stop the sale of the book. All this in the 21^st century in a country which claims to be functioning democracy. When arguing with Pakistan we make it a point to mock at them by claiming to be a democracy. But is this the way a democracy must deal with an important issue as the freedom of expression?

We see the usual goons on the streets during the protests and can be sure that none of them would have read the book. The primary reason being the price tag ($60.74) on the book. The goons may not be paid so much for these sponsored protest. The reason for the reactions against the book is the way we look at our History .We are used to the text book view of history where we have most characters in shades of black and white .We start to take the text book images seriously and treat the characters as demi- gods . When we grow up we are supposed to take a more impartial view of our history and the historical characters.

And we have various political outfits that pick and choose their heroes and villains to further their brand of politics .And we have ambiguous laws which have gaping loop holes and a perennially lethargic judiciary and the executive which fail to deal with law breakers. And we have a situation where we have a few bigots holding the entire society to ransom in the name of hurt sentiments.

It is time we stop living in our past and start thinking seriously about our future. We are a nation with a glorious past and should be proud of it. The people and events from the past should act as inspiration for us to move forward and not as distractions in our march towards future glory. We must realise that History is a chronicle of events involving people with human failings and not a fairy tale involving fictitious characters